TRANSCRIPT Motivational Interviewing with Youth in the VR Setting Thursday, August 8, 2019 >> JESSICA: Hello, everyone. Welcome to this webinar on Motivational Interviewing with Youth in the VR Setting. My name is Jessica. I'm a Y-TAC team member. Before we begin, let's go over a few things. On the top right-hand corner you're able to download our PowerPoint presentation at any time during the webinar. Right below that is our links pod, where you'll see the evaluation. We'd appreciate it if you could take about five minutes to complete this right after the webinar. It helps us ensure we're providing high-quality training and technical assistance. At the bottom right-hand corner, feel free to participate in conversation with everyone else. Feel free to introduce yourself if you'd like. And, okay, that's it. I hope you enjoy this webinar, and I'll hand things over to Karin now. >> KARIN: Good afternoon, or good morning if you're like me and you're in Arizona. I know we have lots of different time zones here. So, welcome to the Y-TAC webinar on Motivational Interviewing with Youth in the VR Setting. Obviously, we're meeting today. And I'm going to introduce you to Adene Karhan, who works with us as a subject-matter expert. She is located at Cornell University. And she is our subject-matter expert on motivational interviewing today. You've got her contact email there, and a lovely picture. I want to tell you a little bit about our evaluation process for Y-TAC. So, it's very important to us that we do show the efficacy of our trainings and our on-site visits. We want to make sure that you get the information that you're looking for out of our trainings. And we want to provide additional professional development opportunities always. So, please, as Jessica said, be sure to complete the evaluation following this session. We do use that information. And we're very grateful. And it helps us prepare and make trainings that are valuable to you, our audience. That's what it's all about. We do also have the availability of CRCs, certified rehab counselor credits. And to receive your CRC credits for this webinar, you have to attend. And at the very end of the webinar, you complete the participation evaluation. And then be sure that you email Jessica, the voice you heard a few minutes ago. The email is listed there. It's spelled out. And you request the form to submit to CR Cs from Jessica. So, let's move on to an introduction to what is Y-TAC? So, the acronym is the Youth Technical Assistance Center. My name is Karin Grandin. I work for the Y-TAC out of D.C. And I am what's called a State Technical Assistance Liaison. The Y-TAC is physically housed under the Institute for Educational Leadership out of D.C. And IEL, we refer to the Institute as IEL, is also partners with Cornell University. Thus, we have Adene joining us as one of our subject-matter experts, as well as Boston University's School of Education. And you've heard me say the SMEs, subject-matter experts, a couple of times already. We also work with lots and various different expertise of SMEs across the country. You're going to hear about motivational interviewing today, but we also have individuals whose expertise is in working with runaway and homeless youth, or programs for individuals who are blind or visually impaired. We have lots of other really good information that we're able to share. So, as I said, Y-TAC is housed under the Institute for Educational Leadership, which is -- I want to say renowned -- but we're definitely a noted partner in the areas of education, equity, obviously workforce development, youth leadership. And the focus is on preparing and supporting young people, their families, and community leaders, and not only supporting them and preparing them, but helping them mobilize to become involved in the systems of improving equity. I'm sorry, I just cut out for a second. Can you hear me? >> Yes, we can hear you, Karin. >> KARIN: Okay. Thank you. So, we're also -- the goal of IEL is to be innovative in terms of strategies for all those populations that I just mentioned we serve and work with. So if you want to learn more about the Institute for Educational Leadership, you can go to www.iel.org. Some of the key things we do at Y-TAC -- I'm a technical assistance liaison. So we work with state VR agencies. And we help them find and engage youth with disabilities who are not in special education. So, you hear a lot about pre-ETS. We're the other side of transition and we help state VR agencies find and engage youth with disabilities who are no longer in school or are not employed. This slide shows you some of our other TACs -- so, technical assistance centers. And we work very closely with all of them. So, we have WINTAC, which many VR agencies have heard of, as well as NTACT, the Promise TA Center, and the National Collaborative on Workforce and Disability, which was also housed at IEL. So I'll go over really quickly what some of those acronyms are. I just said WINTAC, Workforce Innovation and Technical Assistance Center, the National Technical Assistance Center on Transition, and Promoting the Readiness of Minors in Social Security Income, and the NCWD. And now I'm going to hand it over to the fabulous Ms. Adene, and she's going to take it away. >> ADENE KARHAN: Hi. Thank you, Karin. Good afternoon, good morning. Thanks for joining us today. I noticed in the group there seems to be a variety of experiences with motivational interviewing. Thanks for filling out the poll. About 30% of people had no previous training on motivational interviewing. And the other 70% had incorporated it into their work into a varying degree. I think the majority felt -- I don't have it front of me right now. But the majority of people, I think it seemed to go back and forth between about 40 to 45% of you said that you have received training and you sometimes incorporate it into the work that you do. That's about where I expected it to fall. It's something that you may find useful with particular clients. And in particular, the reason that we chose to focus on this topic is that it's showing itself to be a very helpful technique or set of skills to be able to use with youth and with certain specific groups that have historically had difficulty in relationships with service providers, and in accessing the resources that they need in the community. So, we are by no means saying that this is a one size fits all for every clients that you work with, but it is something that provides some useful skills that you may find helpful even in your personal life. I find when my children, who are both adolescents, understanding the way they think and the impact of the way I say things to them, the questions I ask, I have found myself reflecting on how I can incorporate it into my parenting. Thanks for joining us. The one thing I would say about MI -- and MI is what I'm going to use as the initials for motivational interviewing -- on the surface, it appears to be fairly intuitive. And in terms of therapeutic techniques, it has a pretty simple basis, pretty understandable, pretty easy to apply kind of concept, at least on the surface. And I think the more difficult part is the actual art of applying it. And it is an art of being able to incorporate it into your interactions, because we all kind of have a tendency to slip into some habits. And sometimes we come with our own professional biases. What I would encourage you to do if you're been to MI training before and this is a refresher, maybe take it to the next level and think more critically about yourself and your own interactions. And kind of self-assess and check in with yourself about when you are interacting with youth in particular, are you using some of these? Are there some of these strategies that you could incorporate more into your work? Let's look at some of the things that make MI a good match for VR counseling. One of the things research has shown is that motivational interviewing is really effective in addressing a number of behaviors that have been shown to be barriers to employment. And I think I started out with substance abuse. And that's what it's widely associated with. But also things like engagement in mental health treatment, which sometimes is the first step that's necessary in order for somebody to be ready to be pursuing employment. It's really helpful with physical health goals like dieting, diabetes, and certain specific things like epilepsy because there's a need for ongoing medical treatment and a need for monitoring medication and things like that. And also, it's been beneficial in other antisocial behaviors. So, some of those things that are getting in the way may not be what you are thinking that you're going to be speaking about with youth that come into your office. But if you're like me, you may be in the middle of a meeting where you have a new client that comes and suddenly you're talking about something unexpected like substance abuse, and the fact that maybe their usage is one of the things that's decreasing their motivation for pursuing employment. So, it could be that you're quickly thrown into a situation unexpectedly where it's helpful to have some of these skills in your back pocket. The other thing that is really helpful is that it can be applied in a short timeframe. It builds on the strengths and training that a lot of you already have, because you have a desire to work with individuals and to help them pursue goals. So, in doing so, MI kind of adds to the skills that a lot of you already have, and some of the personality qualities that probably made you a good match for being a VR counselor. It's different from other client-centered approaches because it's more directive than some approaches and a little bit more strategic. But it's still allowing them personal choice. And it's still a collaborative approach. So it appears to be something that you are not providing counsel, but you really are providing counsel. It's a way of doing it where the individual feels like they are coming to these decisions on their own. And you're providing support and walking alongside them. That is one of the great things about using motivational interviewing with youth, is that in the end, our hope is that they feel like they came to a decision that was of their own free will, and that somebody didn't coerce them or tell them we had to do this because we're the adults telling them what they have to do. This is a picture of the model of change. And this is something that you may have seen associated with substance abuse and other types of addiction treatment. That's where it started out. But this is something that the theoretical basis of motivational interviewing was based on. So, the motivational interviewing strategy can be meshed with the stage of change that somebody is in. It works really well with the stage of pre-contemplation. So, in employment that's when somebody feels unready to work and is neither willing to work nor interested in looking for work. One would think somebody, by the time they come to you, has made the decision that they want to work. The reality is sometimes maybe they're coming because somebody else made them come and it didn't feel like a choice. Or maybe we know that making a decision is not a linear process. They may have thought they were ready to make a decision and when they got in your office they feel anxious and they're suddenly feeling like they're not ready to make this decision. People can move back and forth between these different stages. Contemplation is the next step. That's also where knowing some of these motivational interviewing strategies is helpful. That's when someone has thought about the possibility of working at some point, but they are experiencing ambivalence. We're going to talk more about ambivalence in a little bit. They have thought about it, but maybe not now, or maybe they're thinking about it, but it's not something they've come up with a specific plan about. You can look at the rest to see where youth and employment fall. Here's some -- I'm going to pause for a minute here, actually, because we do have a polling question. So I'm going -- if you want to go ahead and read that, Karin, that would be great. And then we'll pause for a moment. >> KARIN: I'm happy to. So, the second poll says, a recent meta-analysis of research demonstrated when measuring brief encounters, motivational interviewing showed long-term results blank percent of the time. And your choices are 22%, 38%, 52%, or 64%. I hope that you're not one of those no vote folks and that you're participating with us. It look like, Adene, the majority have decided that it's 52% of the time. >> ADENE KARHAN: You're very close. It's actually 64% of the time. So, that is a really encouraging thing for me to hear. When I think about situations where I may only have half an hour or an hour with an individual and I don't know whether they're going to want to come back and see me again, I don't know where they are in the process. So that's what's also making a good match between motivational interviewing and the VR work that you do. Oftentimes, when you're meeting with somebody, you don't have a long period of time with them to get into really in-depth interventions or counseling in terms of therapy counseling. So motivational interviewing is something that provides you with some skills and some tools that can be applied and have actually shown evidence-based, positive effects with a large number of people in a short period of time. That's great to know. This gives you a comparison. This came from -- you can see noted at the bottom -- from some research that was done in 2011 that matched up vocational rehabilitation and motivational interviewing. They tend to both be client-centered, which is really important. In the field of working with individuals with disabilities, there's really a movement towards being client-centered and allowing individuals to build some of those self-determination skills. So that matches up really well with motivational interviewing in VR. There is a focus on work readiness. And in motivational interviewing, there's a focus on readiness for change. And that change that you would be focusing on would be most likely employment. Sometimes what you may find is that that doesn't match up with what they're ready to change. There may be other behaviors that need to be changed first. The conversation may look like they come and initially it seems like they're pursuing employment, but the discussion is about maybe they need to access other services or change other behaviors first, and then they can come back to you. And then we also have -- there's the tendency to look at informed choice in vocational rehabilitation. And in motivational interviewing, they refer to a menu of options which provide individual choices. And that menu could be something that's written. It could be something you verbally state to them. It's a choice in options rather than telling them specifically one thing they need to do. So, some VR themes that have shown some promise in terms of being addressed with motivational interviewing include things like looking at the values and benefits of employment. And I reference in the reference section, on one of the slides there is actually an article that provides some tools that are printable handouts that you can use with individuals. And I would really encourage you to try some of those things with youth in particular, because sometimes having something written for them can be a way to engage clients who have difficulty feeling comfortable talking with you, or maybe who lack the verbal skills to be able to comfortably carry on a conversation and express themselves. So I would check out some of those resources because you can actually do some pros and cons with them. But looking at what's good about employment, what might be some things that are holding them back. Also, concerns and fears. There's oftentimes a lot of those with youth. Employment is new for them. And they are looking at -- for many of them, venturing out into the world for the first time. And that's a scary thing. They also can have some conflicting feelings about things like personal expectations. Maybe the expectations that their parents had for them versus the expectations that they have for themselves. It is a good fit for some of the things you'll be talking about with youth in terms of your role as a VVR counselor. We want to put this in the context of the age that you're working with, and what's going on in the brain and the body, what the thought processes are like. And research has recently shown that there is a huge change and growth in brain development during adolescence, which is really, to me, is really kind of contrary to what I used to think, and I think what we thought in the field is that we thought this only happened in early childhood, particularly in the first few years, under the age of five. And what they found is there's this other huge brain development which has to do not with the growth and size of the brain in terms of brain matter itself, but it's about the networks, and the neurons, and the connections that are being built. And so it is really an opportunity to be working with youth and to help them learn new skills. And what they found, they used this term called plasticity. And it's this ability for the brain to adapt and create new connections, and rewire itself. So for youth who have maybe come from difficult circumstances where they've experienced trauma or violence, or had modeling that for some reason has caused some thoughts that work isn't important, or they aren't capable of working, maybe they have images of themselves. When youth at this age of adolescence -- interestingly, that's now being defined as 11-24. We're no longer looking at adolescence as being up to 18. We're talking about young adults up to the age of 24 are still considered in this adolescence period. And their brain is vulnerable to toxins at that time, but it's also really open to healing. And it's a really, really crucial window of time in terms of learning new skills, and learning to trust people. With youth that have had difficulty attaching and have had difficult relationships, if they can connect to a safe person -- and that safe person could be you -- it can be transformational in their lives at this age -- not to put any pressure on you or anything. But sometimes as a professional, I have really gotten a sense that I may be the first person that's had a conversation with a youth that caused them to feel hope for their life, or caused them to feel like they have value, maybe the first person who validated their feelings and listened to them. So don't downplay the role that you have in their life. That doesn't mean that you have to go on to take on a mentoring relationship or anything with them. But it means you may be the first example of somebody in their life that shows them that things can be different. That if they haven't been treated with respect, they can be treated with respect. They're a person that deserves to be valued. And sometimes that in and of itself can be transformational. So, the stage that adolescents fall into is they tend to fall into the formal operational stage of cognitive development. And I say tend to because sometimes if you're working with somebody with an intellectual disability, sometimes they are maybe in a more abstract phase. And so it depends on the youth that you're working with. But in general, adolescents tend to shy away from what they call soapboxing. If you just start sharing information with them, they get the basics. They know why smoking is bad. They know why they should be working. From a cognitive basis, they know a set of facts. And they think they know a lot. Sometimes we know they don't know everything they think they know. But they are turned off by the approach of I'm the adult, I'm going to tell you, you're going to listen to me. That is one of the first turnoffs for youth because they want to be treated with respect. They're also grappling with more abstract thoughts. They want to figure things out themselves and not just do it because somebody told them to. They are rebelling against authority because it's developmental. They are learning to become more independent. They're learning to individuate themselves. So we can expect a certain amount of resistance to us saying, do this, don't ask questions. So, we want to be trying some other approaches. And some things to try are to explore they're thinking and their motivation, and to ask them from their perspective, what's influencing their desire to work? What are their parents and friends telling them? Are their friends getting jobs or not? What's going on in their community? All these things are things that are going to shape them. And so these are things that they're looking at and can engage them in conversation about things that move you past that dynamic of you just firing questions at them and telling them what to do, and really engaging in conversations about their motives, their dreams, their hopes, the conflicts that they're struggling with. You want to be also thinking about has anybody talked with them about what comes next, about postsecondary education? What happens with siblings? Do they have siblings that went on to postsecondary education or work? What were their experiences like? In motivational interviewing one of the terms that you will hear used a lot is ambivalence. And ambivalence is seen as a normal part of the process in motivational interviewing. And what it is is, I want to and I don't want to at the same time. There's a lot of that with almost everything that we do. I really want to go to this party, but I'm not sure I want to go. I think it's going to be fun, but maybe it's not. Maybe people won't want to talk to me. You can imagine if a youth has never worked before, when they come to your office for the first time, most likely, even if they're coming for the fifth time, there's going to be a little bit of this ambivalence going on. Maybe they're in a job trying to decide if they want to look for another job. Maybe they're in a job considering whether or not they want to stop that job and go on to postsecondary education and pursue college. So, one of the things that we want to do is we want to avoid what they call the righting reflex. It's not reflux, sorry. It's that desire to argue for change, or what's healthier, what's right. We slip into that when we care about people because we as adults can sometimes see things we know would be in the best interest of the youth we serve. Of course getting a job would be good because they'll have money, and they'll be able to pay their bills, and because of that, they may be able to, you know, move out of a community of poverty where they've experienced violence. We can see all these things. Yet at the same time, that righting reflex can cause a conflict from the beginning. And youth can very quickly shut down. And quite honestly, a lot of it is in the engagement, within the first couple minutes you interact with them, they can decide if they want to work with you, if they can trust you or not. One of the things you want to try to avoid is that righting reflex of just telling them what's right or wrong, what they should do. When we go back to that as a default, we start to lose them. The term that Miller and Rollnick, who established rho as a framework, the analogy they use is that MI should feel like dancing rather than wrestling. When you feel like you're starting to wrestle -- and we can all come up with an image of that -- back off and think about when you're dancing somebody is leading who has a plan of where they want to go. They're leading, but it looks effortless. >> We knew what you meant. >> ADENE KARHAN: Tongue-tied. But it's something that appears very smooth. And it appears as if they are moving together, even though the one person is leading. And it's beautiful to watch. Whereas, you know, wrestling, I would not thinking wrestling is something beautiful. Now, it has, obviously, there are things that people are drawn to. Sometimes people do feel like conflict is good and they may appreciate conflict. But in reality, in the working relationship with youth, this idea of dancing is a good model to have in mind when you are trying to build that engagement. So -- >> Adene. >> ADENE KARHAN: Yes. >> Can I interrupt you for a second? We have a question, as I have this vision of rappers in my head and doing a dance, whatever. So, we have a question from one of our participants. And it is what do you do when the youth is unable to express their ambivalence? They tend to know what an adult thinks what should be done. And as an example, let us say, for example, getting their high school equivalency. What do you do when they are unable to express their ambivalence? >> ADENE KARHAN: I think that we start with -- we'll give examples of open-ended questions. Open-ended questions to me are a good way to open up a conversation that becomes a conversation and in that process to try to encourage them to express their hopes and their dreams. And I think we all can start with an assumption that being a young adult, there's probably some differences between what other people want or expect from them and how they see themselves, or maybe them not really knowing how they see themselves. And so it could be that if those things are there but they haven't articulated it, maybe they don't have the language skills to put that into words. Sometimes I will hypothesize. I might say I'm thinking, given your age, sometimes it might be difficult to have parents saying now it's time to get a job, or that you have to get your high school diploma when school is so hard. Can you tell me a little bit about what it feels like to be you? Those are some kinds of questions I would use to open it up and acknowledge. Sometimes they'll give you nonverbal cues. You'll see them nodding when you articulate something that's already there they haven't been able to express. Usually it's a quick nod like, yes, I wanted to say that but I couldn't. Then it starts the conversation. So it's something we can assume is there, and we can ask some questions that can try to get at it. Or sometimes maybe they know what they want to do. It could be that you have some youth that come to you and they are doing what everybody expected and they're okay with that. I think it's just a matter of checking in and making sure that we're going the route of self-determination, of helping them make choices and to identify their wants and their needs and preferences so that we're following what they want, not what everybody else wants for them. That's a great question. And I think definitely would be a great thing to be discussing, because I'm sure people have other examples of situations where that's happened, things they've talked about, or questions they've asked. So, thank you for that. So, the MI process is -- in a nutshell, these four different stages -- engaging, which is going to be establishing that connection, that working relationship for whatever period of time it is. And engaging to me, there's a period of that that is going to happen in those first five minutes that you meet with somebody. Those first five minutes are really crucial because they're going to decide can I work with this person, can I trust this person. focusing, telling them a bit of what you do. Asking them open-ended questions and using some of these techniques to try to figure out if you're on the same page with what you want to do and what they came to you for. Evoking is to try to elicit their own motivation. Do they buy into this change, do they want to work, to go to school? Would they rather be doing something else, is there something else getting in the way. Evoking is the heart of motivational interviewing. You're trying to bring out of them information about their motivation level. And what are they motivated to do? They're motivated to do something. Sometimes it's not something that everybody else wants. We still want to start with where they're at. It's helpful information to find out what is motivating them. If that's something like drugs or alcohol, or things their friends are doing, a really good question to ask is how is that working for you? That can be said in a flippant way. But if you say it in a genuine way, you can get them to open up. I have a friend whose son was making some poor decisions. I engaged him in a conversation about, what is it like for you? What does it feel like when you get high? How do you feel afterwards? I think because they know that you're not just going to discard the fact that there are some positive things that they get from those drugs, they're also more willing to share some of the negatives. So I think we sometimes have to be willing to go there and really have them talk openly with us about the decisions they're making. The last part is planning. That's when they have gotten to a point where you're able to move ahead and make some decisions about change. And I think we're going to do another poll right now. So, do we have the poll? No, I'm sorry, that's the wrong place. I had it there before. So this is a term I think is interesting that is something I had heard about before. I hadn't heard it termed as this. And it's something that I think is useful to keep in mind. Equipoise is a conscious, intentional decision not to use one's professional presencen and skills to influence a client towards making a specific choice. There is such a desire to tell a client what to do. We come to an assumption about what somebody needs or could change in their life. People could come to the same kind of assumptions about us about things that they think we should do differently. We need to reflect on how well we take that when somebody says what we need to do. So, equipoise is that ability to step back. In the medical profession this would be a doctor who tells you what your diagnosis is and gives you some information to make an informed choice, but does not tell you specifically which option you have to choose. And I think that that for me is something that I really value in medical professionals. Because I want to feel like I looked at the information myself. I weighed the pros and cons. And in the end I made a decision that was best for me. And I didn't just do something because a medical professional told me that I should. So, it's a mental approach. But it really is something that can be helpful as a framework, something to remind you of as you're doing your work. And not just with motivational interviewing. That's an approach in general that I had to really use when I was doing counseling and when I do counseling, because there's a tendency to give feedback even when we don't realize it. Sometimes it's a tone of voice. Sometimes it's the way we frown when somebody says something. I can clearly tell when I am doing something that my doctor approves of and when I'm doing something that the doctor doesn't approve of. And sometimes that's verbal things they say, but sometimes it's something more subtle like a facial expression. We have to be really mindful of the messages we're giving from the nonverbal avenues as well as the verbal. So, one thing to think about -- this is huge with youth -- is that first encounter. Here are some strategies that come from the research on motivational interviewing specific to adolescents. And the first is to make the most of your first impression. By developing a good opening statement. And I know this might sound hokey, but this is something that can be really useful. If you're not comfortable and don't have a lot of experience working with youth, I would encourage that you do a little bit of scripting and thinking about what you want to do when you first meet them so you can have a meaningful interaction. And you want to emphasize that you are thankful they came and they made the choice to show up. You also want to be monitoring your intensity. The interesting thing is that we can come across as being standoffish, grumpy, or mean with some of our negative affect. But on the flip side, if you appear too overly enthusiastic, that can also cause youth to shut down if it's not congruent with what's going on internally with them. They may feel like you don't get them, don't understand them. I have had people -- I know in the mental health realm that sometimes if people are experiencing depression, it's hard for them to be around people that are upbeat and too chipper, because it feels incongruent with their mood. And because it's incongruent, it's uncomfortable so they're not engaged the same way. Be thinking about your affect. You want to have a neutral -- friendly, but not overly friendly, overly chipper and annoyingly cheerful. You want to set an agenda is number two, to illustrate your approach to collaboration. That could be something that you have in writing. You may want to take the time to write something up that gives an overview of some of the things that you typically look to accomplish during that first meeting. Or it could be something that they call -- there's an agenda map which basically -- if you Google agenda map, you can find online worksheets. But it's also as easy as taking a piece of paper, drawing circles on it, putting names in those circles, and they include things like you have a circle for education, work, family, and in that you can write down or they can write down what things are on their agenda to talk about, what are some of the barriers that are getting in the way, what are natural supports. That's a great way to map out what you want to talk about and what they want to talk about. And you can also just take a piece of paper and say let's write down together what I want to talk about, what you want to talk about, questions you might have. It shows collaboration. If they're nervous, if they're anxious, if they are triggered because they've been exposed to trauma, what we know is that knowing what comes next is really important. And it helps people become more comfortable and regulated. So an agenda is a really good way to start an initial meeting because it tells them what's going to come next. To go along with that, you want to be thinking about applying a trauma-informed lens, thinking this person may be in a state of fight or flight where they do not feel comfortable coming to a service provider and sitting in an office. You want to think about how you can make them feel welcome. That could be things like even how you set up your room, and the kind of lighting that you have. And maybe you offer them a drink of water. Maybe you just make chit-chat first to help them feel comfortable, to make sure they're physically comfortable in the room. The OARS, you've probably heard in reference to some specific skills that are used in motivational interviewing. The OARS are basically -- O is for asking open-ended questions. The A is affirming. The R is reflective listening. And the S is summarizing. And this gives you -- I'm going to start with the questions. You may or may not have heard this. This comes from Miller. It's DARN, the acronym for questions that can inspire change. This list gives you ideas. If you feel like you slip into a rut of asking questions, which sometimes when we do something for a while, when we're doing the same thing over and over we fall into a habit of asking the same kind of questions. It can sometimes feel interrogative to people to come into intake meetings and other places where they have to fill out forms and we have to ask them factual questions, it can feel uncomfortable like we're just firing things at them. And so you want to be alternating that with other meaningful questions. If you have to gather information, think about asking some of the questions in a different way. Ask them about their desires. How would they like things? What are they looking for? Ability questions, how would they go about things. Get them to highlight some of their strengths. Reasons, what are some of their reasons for considering change? When we can get them to articulate their reasons, then we can start to move towards some goals, because we're then building on their own internal motivations and we're starting to engage in change talk. And their need for change. What needs to happen? If you want to do X, Y, and Z, what would need to happen? How urgent does this feel to you? These are some questions that can help to frame your conversation if you're wondering how to get things going. Some other tools that are useful -- yes. >> KARIN: Hi. I just wanted to point out the significance of that previous slide and what it means to VR counselors and your statement about how sometimes we tend to shotgun questions. And what this proves to me is that there is a way for the VR counselors who have to fill out their case management system, and look at their computer while they're trying to meet with somebody, to get some of those real specific questions answered that they have to get for the data purposes. But you can get them by using some of these techniques and these questions. And so you can meet both objectives, to ask open-ended questions and still get your data points met. >> ADENE KARHAN: Right. Honestly, I've seen the difference. I've observed in people the difference. So, for example, at the agency where I work, I've seen the difference in approaches to intake. There's always an intake when new clients come in. There would be an intake to find out what brings them in. It comes with a bunch of questions about medical, occupational history, mental health, lots of different things that have to be asked that are on a form. And the form is many pages long. There is a huge difference in the response with the therapist who just sticks to the form and fills out the clipboard without eye contact, and the ones that ask for a more narrative response, starting with can you tell me what brings you here today, what you're looking for today. And that's not to say that you won't revert back to some of those questions. Obviously you want to make sure those questions get answered. But even alternating some of them so they're able to tell their story in whatever way they need to. It doesn't mean you need to have a three-hour meeting with them. But it is a style of asking questions that makes it feel like you're engaging in meaningful conversation, not just trying to fill out a form. So thank you for sharing that. I appreciate that. So, here's some additional tools. And these are things that -- there are examples. If you decide you want some examples of these, send me an email and I'll send you resources. They have different forms of rulers. That would be something you could have on a form. I've seen people have forms that have -- they go online and get a template of a picture of a ruler. They insert things. You can do it for lots of different things. Usually you go on a scale of zero to ten and identify for the client what zero and ten are. On a scale of zero to ten with zero being I don't want to work and ten being I want to work, where do you fall? You can also have them do it with a question of what skills do they feel like they have? How ready to work are they? How many barriers, how likely do they feel that they are going to get a job? There are lots of different ways to use that that you can apply to employment. How fearful are they? If you sense a little bit of fear, on a scale of 0-10 with zero being not scared to ten being I'm scared out of my mind, where do you fall? That's also a means when you meet with them again of measuring progress to see if that number changes. Another thing that's helpful with youth is the querying extremes. You ask them to describe the extremes of their concerns. What's your worst fear if you don't get a job by the time you graduate? Get them to go there in their head. Then the conversation becomes instead of letting that paralyze you because you're afraid, let's use that as a way to develop a plan. This is what you want to prevent. What are some things we can put in place that can help you to prevent that worst thing that you're afraid of from happening? Another thing is to help them to look forward and ask them questions about what do they want life to look like five years from now. And as difficult as it is to believe, some youth have not thought that far ahead. I guess maybe it's not that difficult. Youth don't think ahead. But some youth in particular have experienced so much trauma that they live for the moment and don't think about the future or are too afraid to think about the future. Hoping and dreaming might be new for them. The thought that good things could happen in the future for them might be a new thought. That might be something that might introduce motivation to them. And then exploring values. Ask them what's important to them and what they value. There's good examples online of cards you can laminate. And if you have the time, you can take a few minutes and ask youth to sort it out and pick out the five things they value the most. When you have their values it's a good way to engage them in conversations about motivation. And you build on those values -- what do they care about, how can you link that to what you're working on with them. Affirmation, the A in OARS. It's fairly straightforward. The thing you want to avoid is, with youth, sometimes you can seem phony if you make general affirmations. Like, if you're always telling them oh, you're just so good at everything -- I've had people say their parents are like that. I don't believe she really thinks I do a good job, because even when I stink, she tells me I do a good job. But they don't need that from their counselor. They need something that is genuine, not something that person just says as a line to all of the people they work with. Saying you're so talented may be true. That's not a bad thing to say. But it's probably more helpful to state specifically something that they did well. Wow, I saw you went to this meeting and you participated in your IEP meeting. And that's amazing, because I know that took a lot of effort for you. Or, I heard back from your employer and they told me that you have really shown a lot of initiative at work, because you've taken on some new tasks. And this is what they said. So, telling them specific feedback you got, you want to try to give them affirmation. You don't need to do it all the time, otherwise maybe it will seem disingenuine. Reflective listening is listening to what's being said and forming a hypothesis. They indicated in some of the literature that this is kind of a joke among people about therapists and how they can tell somebody is a therapist because people reflect back is sounds like you feel dot dot dot. And it is true to some extent that is built into the therapy profession, that we do reflective listening. But, it's not supposed to be something you do to somebody that makes them feel uncomfortable. And if you just parrot things back to them it can be something that really causes them to shut down. So, what you want to do, in some cases, they recommend dropping the stem. Don't say, it sounds like. The moment they hear that, my kids are probably like Mom, you're being a social worker or therapist. My daughter complained the other day that's the hardest thing about being the daughter of a therapist. She can tell I'm trying to get her to talk about her feelings. Some youth are resistant to that. You want to not make this feel like a therapy session. There is a time and purpose for that. Honestly, that, in some situations, is my role that I need to get them to talk about their feelings. You don't need to make it feel like a therapy session. Sometimes it might even be reflecting on their behavior and saying what I'm gathering from your behavior is that you feel frustrated by your parents or whatever. Even the way I said that you probably wouldn't say, I'm gathering what your feeling. That would not come across well. You may want to do scripting to make sure it feels natural. You want to reflect what you're hearing and seeing and form a hypothesis and see what they say. A really good example of this is I had a boy I was working with on a transition grant that we had. Nobody could get him to go to school. He was 14. His grandmother couldn't get him to go. They had people from the school, there were physical altercations when they tried to get him to go to school. He was completely shut down. I was assigned to work with this family, to do some family coaching. I went in and introduced myself. He kind of grunted at me. I started to talk with his grandmother. He went to the kitchen. I was thinking, what can I do differently? Everybody has already tried to talk with him about different things. One of the first things I said, within the first few sentences, was, you know, it seems to me like maybe you're feeling bored. I'm wondering what school is like for you. And he stopped what he was doing -- making lunch. He looked at me. And he said, you know, you intrigue me. I have never had anybody ask me that before. And then we went on. We had a conversation. We were able to get him to agree to at least set up a visit to go look at a school. I'm not saying that that was like a quick fix solution and everything went great from there. But it was a way to change up the conversation. Because I was able to ask him something that nobody had asked him before and it changed the dynamic. It wasn't specifically -- I think what I did was take his behaviors and made a hypothesis. I think he might be really bright and bored. Everybody assumes because of his behavior, he was in special education classes. He has a very high IQ. He was bored. It was a cycle of he would misbehave and they would continue to discipline. Then he didn't want to go to school. Anyway. Moving on. Summary statements are another thing to have in your toolkit. Summaries capture what was said, especially if you've talked about a lot of things and you've given them new information. At the end or partway through the meeting with them, you can summarize some of the things that you talked about together. Discrepancy is one of the terms that you'll hear a lot in motivational interviewing. It's the distance between where a client is and where he or she wants to be. And what we want to do is to create a safe place for individuals to look at themselves in the mirror, assess an uncomfortable truth about themselves, and let it change them. Maybe they are making a choice that everybody has told them they shouldn't make -- they're engaging in some kind of high-risk behavior. We want them to be able to look in the mirror and see that they have value and they have within themselves the ability to make this change because they want a different outcome, not because everybody told them they should. Miller and Rollnick had a great quote -- the function of a mirror is to reflect the image as it is. We do not want a sermon. We may not like the image we see. Still, we would rather decide for ourselves our next move. We don't want to be overly optimistic or set expectations too high or say things that are untrue. We want to reflect back to them in a way that helps them to see -- maybe some of the consequences. Help them to articulate what are some of the drawbacks of the unhealthy behavior they're engaging. This is a decisional balance tool. This slide gives you a look at what you can do on a piece of paper. This article at the bottom is the one that I had mentioned before that I would really suggest that if you want more tools like this, you take a look at. They have a worksheet for this, along with several others. They're specifically for professionals who are working in the employment sector. So, all the questions are geared towards employment. So this gives you an idea of the pros and cons. It's a tangible way of using that tool. And I think now we do have a polling question, correct? >> Yes, we do. And it is, within the framework of MI, motivational interviewing, advice can be given A. at any time, B. never, C. when you ask for and receive permission from the client or consumer, and D. when the client/consumer is engaging in a behavior that conflicts with the goal of your agency. And I would say everybody is pretty much agreeing that it is C. when you ask for and receive permission from the client/consumer. How did they do? >> ADENE KARHAN: They did great. Absolutely. Gold star for everybody who put that answer. Yes, in particular we do want to ask permission. And the kicker with that is if they say no, I don't want to get information about this, then you have to step back and say, okay, well, they don't want to talk about this. But then there's another question of what can I do to help. If we're going to ask for permission, we have to be okay with their answer. What they say, based on interventions and research that is done about this in terms of the effect, the effect is that it builds that working alliance so you feel comfortable because they know you're not just like that car salesman who's going to tell them what they want to hear. You're not that person who doesn't have their best interest in mind. You're going to listen to them and take to heart what they say. If they say no, they don't want that, you're not going to try to push it on them. So, discord is what it sounds like. It's a disharmony in the collaborative relationship. That's something that can come across like it could be them actually yelling at you, or confronting you, or disagreeing with what you say. But it can be a little bit more subtle like disengaging and becoming distracted. We want to be careful. It might mean we have fallen into what they call in motivational interviewing the premature focus trap. We have decided that we're ready to go in a direction and move in that direction whether that person is ready to or not. We want to step back and check in with them. We want to figure out what's not lining up with where they're wanting to go. We want to engage in conversation about that. Some things that you can do really easily are to apologize and say, if you have offended them or you see some response from them that shows that they are experiencing some negative reactions, you can say sorry, I just realized I slipped into lecturing you like you were one of my kids. I don't want to be like your mom. Let's talk a little bit more, what would you like me to know about the situation? Or affirming -- I can see that you really spent a lot of time thinking about this. You can affirm the fact that they've spent time reflecting. And shifting focus, sometimes you want to shift away from that danger zone and you want to help them to engage in talk that helps them to feel supported rather than going after that conflict. You're not going to win that battle in that moment. What you want to do is go back and try to reestablish that therapeutic alliance with them. These are some perceptions that are consistent with motivational interviewing. I am the expert on why and how this -- inconsistent. I don't know if I said consistent. These are inconsistent. I am the expert on why and how this person should change. My job is to collect information about problems. That goes back to some of those forms we have to fill out. That's what this person is to me, somebody who's just a means of me getting the answers. I rectify gaps in knowledge. When I find out you don't know something, it's my job to fill in those blanks. Frightening information is helpful in promoting change. That's the approach we've taken a lot with drugs and alcohol, we're going to show them bad things. And they're finding that that's not necessarily the best approach. >> We have a few questions. The first one is, any tips on not sounding super measured when using MI? This person finds that those conversations can be kind of clunky and it takes more time to formulate good, engaging questions. Any tips on that? >> Adene, if you're talking, you're on mute. >> ADENE KARHAN: I'm sorry. Thank you. So, I think that a good starting point is to look at some of the things that are suggested by Miller and Rollnick. If you go to the book, or I have some samples of motivational interviewing training books and things that I downloaded that I can send to somebody. But look at examples of what's recommended and then spend some time practicing how you would put that into your own words. I think the most important thing is that you want it to sound natural to you and how you talk. They'll be able to tell. It's not going to feel normal to you. I can't give you a one size fits all, what's not going to feel clunky. It won't feel clunky if it matches up with your style. If you're a formal speaker it might be fine. But if you speak less formal, you want to work on it and practice. Unfortunately, that's something that when we first learn things, we have to take the time to do. We do it in private. We model it for supervisors and coworkers. Motivational interviewing works best when there's coaching and you're getting feedback about how it's going. You can practice that with other people and fine-tune what is normal for you to say. With clients and the conversations you have, how can you take these messages and tweak them so that they feel normal for you. That was a great question. >> We have another question. What do you do with that young person who you ask them what do they really want to do, or really want, and they say, I don't know? >> ADENE KARHAN: (Laughing) Which is kind of where a lot of youth are at. And I think that a good place to start with that might be to help them to look at -- you know, that might be a good way to talk about some of the assessments that you could do with them, because you may have to start -- really start back in terms of, you know, you're coming assuming certain things that they may want. You may want to go back to finding out what are their interests and preferences. It varies in terms of what kind of assessments you do. But my thought would be that that would be a good time to share some of the things that you could do to help them figure out what are their career preferences, what do they want with their vision for the future. There's lots of person-centered planning tools. I would say person-centered planning would come into effect there. But it could be give them a menu of options of some of the things that your agency could offer, because they may not have any idea -- okay, I've come to this place, I don't know what they do. You could share some information. That might be a helpful thing to say. I know you're not sure what you want, let me tell you what we do, and check in with them along the way to see if they have more questions. Then maybe give them a little bit of time to reflect on some things, or connect them to maybe somebody who can do some career exploration with them that helps them start with what do I want to do before I try to go get a job. What kind of job do I want, what are my interests and preferences. Again, that's a great question. Because with youth, there are going to be times where you're going to get that. And you may also want to do more writing-type of activities, or sometimes artwork. It may be that verbally it's hard for them to tell you what they want. But you could use pictures. There's great resources on Pinterest and other places where there are sorting cards you can do with different careers and occupations, and people doing different things. For kids who have difficulty with the language piece of it and processing and articulating what they want, you could have them do card or picture sorting and things like that to give them different ways to articulate what they are interested in. Here's some consistent assumptions you can have. I have expertise and consumers are the experts on themselves. I find out what information consumers want and need. It's not just driven by what I want. I match information the consumer needs with strengths. And consumers can tell me what kind of information is helpful. This is another thing you'll see referenced. This is a great model to keep on hand, the EPE technique -- elicit, provide, elicit. If they said I don't know what I want to do, you could ask permission to share some information. Like do you know anything about what VR is able to offer? If they don't, you can say is it okay if I share some information? You can provide. That gives you tips about avoiding jargon and offer a small amount at a time. Then ask for feedback, ask if they're interested in the information you gave. You can go through that process many times within a meeting with somebody. You give some information, you check in with them, and then see if they have any questions and then give a little bit more information. And what they suggest when you get to a point where you can feel like they're ready to make is change is that you test the water. Would you like to talk about the next steps that might be in the VR process? Or you can recapitulation is a great word. I have all kinds of images in my head of what that is. I think it's somebody verbally vomiting and you giving them the summary. But it's a brief summary of one of the reasons for change that you've heard, or some of the reasons for change. So you can kind of collect all of them in a basket, because a lot of times people will come and be all over the place with what they're telling you. That's okay. One of the things that you can do as a professional is to put a little pin mark in those. You can even jot them down. You can have something -- I would try to keep eye contact as much as you can. When you hear them say something that sounds like a good agenda item or something that could be a goal or motivation for them, jot it down so at the end you can go back and say let me just summarize some of the things I heard you say and make sure I heard you right. And then another thing is that you could ask a simple question. What would you you like to do? Would you like to work together? That's a really good question. It's scary to ask. How does it feel to you to work with me? Do we work okay as a team? We're afraid of getting rejected. Even if it's not a client you would want to work with, you want them to want to work with you. It's hard to ask but it gives them a sense that they have some control over this. It's really empowering sometimes to be able to ask that. If they say they're not ready to move forward, you can respect that. And honestly, the people that I have got cards from tend to be the salesmen that say, thinking about this. Talk to other salesmen. Look around. Call me if you have any questions. I trust them because I know they're not just telling me what I want to hear so they can get my money or they can get what they want. I would take that approach. These are some things about what you don't want to do. Miller and Rollnick say it's as much as about what you don't do as what you do. Don't prescribe, be a guide. Support autonomy. We don't want to immediately jump to problem-solving and make people feel like we have all the answers and how could they not figure this out on their own because we have all the answers. They don't hear that the right way. That's disempowering. We want to create an atmosphere of acceptance, that we see them as more than a collection of bad behaviors that people have maybe told us about. We don't want to emphasize external demands like what their parents want or why you think they should change. You want to elicit it from them and you want that to come from them. And the thing I want to leave you with at the end of this is some self-assessment questions to check in with yourself. This gives you a way to look at the different levels of motivational interviewing and see how you think you're doing with it. You may ask someone to observe your interactions and give you feedback. You may pick one at a time to work on. You may find one feels -- you feel like you're strong in some of them, not as much in others. You might want to pick one or two to focus on. These come as a way of assessing how you're doing. With that, this gives you some of the references I used. Feel free to let me know, email me if there's something I mentioned you would like me to forward for you. Now we can open it up if there are more questions, or more discussion. This is the time for us to be able to chat a little bit more. >> KARIN: So, we're a little over time, Adene. So I'm going to -- if folks want to hang on for a few more minutes, I can ask one of the questions remaining in the chat box. >> ADENE KARHAN: I had the wrong time. Sorry about that. If anyone wants to email me questions, that's great, too. I apologize, because I was just totally flipped on the time there. >> We're good on time. The webinar ends at 3:30. >> I thought it was 3:00. Never mind. >> ADENE KARHAN: In my head I thought -- okay, good. Yes, if anybody has any questions, we can chat. >> KARIN: Okay. So one of the questions asked was how can supervisors, administrators, or managers help their staff working with youth to build their skills, their MI skills? >> ADENE KARHAN: Well, one of the things that is given as feedback in, you know, some of the literature from Miller and Rollnick who developed the model, and also in some of the other guidebooks for organizations that have really incorporated this as a model is a lot of coaching and feedback. They really emphasize -- as much as, you know, I think it's helpful to introduce some of these terms as either an introductory overview or a refresher, really the way that these skills are incorporated into work in a way that they really are comfortable in the long term is with somebody giving some feedback on how you're doing with them and practicing them maybe with case studies or practicing in staff meetings. And I know people have different levels of comfort with doing skits and things like that. In social work, we did that a lot. And I came to enjoy it. But it was in a setting where that's what you did. I think if you can make that a part of your setting, even though it's awkward at first, people can go with it. The hands-on practicing is the best. I attended a suicide prevention training. It was based on the style of providing information. Then we had to apply it by -- we had to do roleplay on the spot, and come up with a client and a story. One person assumed the role of the client. The other was the therapist. There was no script. We had to go with it because that's how life happens. You're having conversations. You don't know what they're going to say next. You have to think on your feet. That's one of the best ways to practice motivational interviewing. With this one they would have people standing on a bridge as if they had to jump. We had to go up and say something. That person who was getting ready to jump had to indicate to us whether they felt like the person's response was something that caused them to want to think more about coming down from where they were ready to jump. That's a really intense -- obviously, that was a suicide prevention class. But it was kind of a motivational interviewing style. So you can do something similar in a staff meeting. Or you could do it in one-on-one scenarios that you practice with a coworker or in supervision meetings with your staff. I don't know -- if somebody else has suggestions or resources you want to share with people, you can put that in the chat box. If you've come across a particular book or website, or resource, or type of activity that has worked well, I think that's a great way to share those, too. So you can put something in the chat box. >> KARIN: Do we have any other questions that people would like to post? One thing, Adene, people really want your materials. We've offered that we will put them on the Y-TAC website. But you will also see Adene's email here in the chat box. And it's earlier in the presentation -- the PowerPoint presentation as well. >> ADENE KARHAN: Yes. I have some longer things. If there's something specific that you're interested in -- I have some articles -- I have folders of things that I put them into, like motivational interviewing research that they've done related to employment and things like that. Some people really like journal articles, some people don't. There's a manual I downloaded that is about 200 pages, maybe 250. And it has some scenarios of activities that you can do to practice some of these skills. And it wasn't for employment, I don't believe. I can't remember what type of agency it was that wrote it. But that would be a really good manual for organizations that are looking at wanting to practice and just want a variety of different activities that are already written. So, if there's something specific that you don't see and you are interested in it, just send me an email and let me know what type of information and I can send you what I have. I would highly recommend the Miller and Rollnick. And the other one is Motivational Interviewing with Adolescents by Suarez. They give scenarios and scripts of specific things that are said by the practitioner and by the client. Now, some of it would be for counseling sessions for people that are doing therapy. But the principles in most of the book are principles that are good across the board with any type of counseling interactions that you have with youth. >> KARIN: Last call for any questions if you'd like to post them in the chat box. If not, I'll just remind folks, please, please take our little survey. You see the link there in the chat box. It's also on the PowerPoint. We really appreciate you taking the time. It's quick and we need the information, and you can tell Adene how fabulous she was. I told you guys. And then a reminder for those of you who are seeking CRC credits that you fill out the form and send it to Jessica. >> ADENE KARHAN: Thank you very much. I appreciate all of you for joining us today. And if you have any additional questions, feel free to send them to me. I'm happy to chat with people about different things, especially when it pertains to working with youth. And I hope you all have a great day. >> KARIN: Thank you very much, Adene, and thank you all. We had great representation from 12 different states. Have a great rest of your day. >> Thank you, Karin, and Jessica. >> Bye. >> Bye-bye. Just a reminder to everyone to please complete the evaluation so you can get CRC credits. The CRC will be coming to you once you email me. And I'll be emailing you guys back the CRC form at the end of August once I know it's been approved. Okay? Again, at the end of August is when you'll be receiving them. Thank you so much, everyone. Have a good day. Bye-bye.